Ethereum Co-Founder Vitalik Buterin Urges Canadians to Oppose Bill C-22

Abstract:Vitalik Buterin has urged Canadians to contact senators over Bill C-22, whose technical-access rules have raised concerns about encryption and privacy.

Ethereum co-founder Vitalik Buterin has urged Canadians to contact senators about Bill C-22, comparing the proposed law to the European Unions “Chat Control” debate.

In a November 17 post on X, Buterin wrote that “Canada is going through its own version of the Chat Control mess with the C-22 bill.” He urged Canadians to support “backdoor-free, no asterisks” end-to-end encryption, which he called important to a “secure, free and open society.”

He urged governments to “minimize all backdoors and mass data collection” as AI changes cybersecurity risks. He linked to an October 8 Mozilla paper warning about Bill C-22s effect on encryption.

Canada is going through its own version of the Chat Control mess with the C-22 bill:https://t.co/bqdpOMdGRj

Highly encourage fellow Canadians to contact senators and make clear how you feel about the importance of (backdoor-free, no asterisks) end-to-end encryption, and its…

— vitalik.eth (@VitalikButerin) November 17, 2026

Meanwhile, the Lawful Access Act, 2026, has not become law. The House of Commons passed it on June 18, and the Senate approved second reading on October 22 before referring it to the Standing Senate Committee on National Security, Defence and Veterans Affairs.

The committees November 16 hearing included Meta, Signal, privacy advocates and legal experts. The bill remains in committee, with report stage, third reading and royal assent still pending.

Part 2 would let the government require providers to develop and maintain technical capabilities for lawful access. The order itself does not grant data access.

The bill does not expressly require providers to decrypt end-to-end messages

The legislation defines electronic service providers broadly. It covers organizations that create, store, process, transmit, receive or make electronic information available, provided they serve people in Canada or conduct business there. It does not name crypto exchanges, wallet providers or self-custody apps.

The House-passed version says the act cannot force a provider to decrypt information encrypted by a customer, or ensure authorities can decrypt it, unless the provider supplied the encryption and holds the information needed to unlock it. Providers are similarly not required to follow technical obligations that would introduce a systemic vulnerability or prevent them from fixing one. The bills definition of systemic vulnerability excludes risks tied only to people covered by a warrant or other legal authority.

The House-passed text leaves the core-provider schedule blank for future regulations. Those providers could be required to retain specified metadata for up to six months. Metadata can include the date, time, duration, origin and destination of an exchange. The bill excludes rules requiring retention of message content, web-browsing history or social media activity.

The public safety minister could issue orders to any electronic service provider, including those outside the core-provider category. Orders could impose the same technical and metadata obligations, last up to two years and require approval from the Intelligence Commissioner. Providers must have an opportunity to make representations, although the legislation restricts disclosure of the orders.

Crypto wallets could fall within the broad provider definition

Some crypto businesses could fall within the definition. A centralized exchange or hosted wallet serving Canadians may qualify if it stores account details or processes customer transactions.

The text does not expressly list exchanges or wallet apps, and it does not require self-custody developers to hold users private keys. Its decryption clause protects customer-encrypted information when a provider does not hold the necessary key. Whether a particular wallet developer or privacy tool qualifies would depend on how its service operates.

Ottawa says investigators still need legal authorization to obtain personal information and that the bill grants no direct access to company systems.

Privacy groups say the safeguards do not settle the debate

Mozilla argued in its October paper that “there is no safe way to create exceptional access to encrypted data that only the intended actor can use.” It warned that companies could be required to create capabilities that bypass existing protections or provide access to data before encryption.

In a November 2 statement to senators, Privacy Commissioner Philippe Dufresne welcomed amendments that “preclude requirements to decrypt end-to-end encrypted information.” He nevertheless called for further changes, including clearer limits on subscriber information and a requirement that obligations be necessary and proportionate. His statement to senators outlined those recommendations.

The UN Human Rights Office said in comments dated November 3 that Bill C-22 “threatens to undermine end-to-end encryption” and recommended an explicit provision protecting critical technical safeguards. The Canadian Civil Liberties Association has cited the UN comments in its call for amendments.

The EU comparison has limits. The blocs long-term child sexual abuse proposal concerns detecting and reporting abuse material, including disputed scanning of private communications. Talks on detection remain unresolved. A separate temporary EU measure allowing voluntary detection runs until April 3, 2028, and excludes end-to-end encrypted communications, according to the Council of the EU.

Buterin has described an AI agent using Tor and local prompt rewriting. The Ethereum Foundation has backed default wallet privacy through its Kohaku software development kit. In December 2025, Buterin allocated 256 ETH to Session and SimpleX Chat, as crypto.news previously reported.

Disclaimer

The views in this article only represent the author's personal views, and do not constitute investment advice on this platform. This platform does not guarantee the accuracy, completeness and timeliness of the information in the article, and will not be liable for any loss caused by the use of or reliance on the information in the article.
Previous Post

Gary Gensler warns AI bubble could burst before Bitcoin's 2028 halving

Next

BlackRocks Bitcoin ETF snaps $2.35B outflow streak amid extreme fear