US judge acquits MIT brothers in $25 million Ethereum fraud case, citing lack of deception

요약:A US judge acquitted Anton and James Peraire-Bueno in a $25 million Ethereum MEV case after finding insufficient evidence of material deception.

A U.S. federal judge has acquitted brothers Anton and James Peraire-Bueno of criminal charges stemming from a $25 million Ethereum trading operation that prosecutors alleged was executed in just 12 seconds.

In a 46-page opinion and order filed on Nov. 16, U.S. District Judge Jessica G. L. Clarke ruled that prosecutors had failed to establish a material misrepresentation, an essential element of wire fraud.

The decision clears the Massachusetts Institute of Technology-educated brothers of wire fraud, conspiracy to commit wire fraud and conspiracy to commit money laundering. Their trial ended in a mistrial in November 2025 after jurors failed to reach a unanimous verdict.

US judge finds no material deception in Ethereum trading case

Much of Clarkes ruling examined the rules governing Ethereum and whether participants make explicit or implicit promises when submitting transactions, registering validators or interacting with software used to organize blockchain transactions.

“It is a trustless, highly adversarial environment with no terms of use,” Clarke wrote, describing Ethereum.

Federal prosecutors argued that the brothers‘ trading activity involved deception because they deliberately placed transactions designed to attract automated trading bots before disrupting the bots’ intended trades.

Clarke rejected the argument that submitting a transaction to Ethereums public pool of pending transactions amounted to an agreement that it would be executed alongside other trades in a particular order.

The judge found that the government‘s comparison with spoofing in traditional financial markets was equally problematic. Unlike orders placed with the intention of canceling them, the brothers’ bait transactions were never withdrawn and appeared on the blockchain within approximately one minute of the operation.

Neither Ethereum nor the MEV-Boost software specifications established the obligations that prosecutors claimed the brothers had violated, the ruling said.

How the brothers made $25 million from Ethereum trading bots

At the center of the prosecution was a trading operation called Omakase, which targeted cryptocurrency traders engaged in a practice known as sandwich trading.

Sandwich trading is a form of maximal extractable value, or MEV, in which automated programs seek profits by influencing the order in which transactions appear on a blockchain.

A sandwich bot typically purchases tokens before another users pending buy order and sells them afterward, benefiting from the price movement caused by the intervening transaction.

Court records show that the Peraire-Bueno brothers spent months preparing Omakase and registered 16 Ethereum validators capable of facilitating the operation.

In April 2023, eight transactions attracted sandwich traders whose automated programs assembled trades intended to profit from the brothers purchases.

The operation involved a vulnerability in relay software associated with MEV-Boost, an open-source tool introduced by Flashbots in 2022. The vulnerability exposed transaction information that would ordinarily remain hidden from validators until they committed to publishing a proposed block.

Using that information, the brothers altered the proposed arrangement of transactions, disrupting the sandwich traders expected sales and generating approximately $25 million in profits.

Three sandwich traders suffered losses, including Savannah Technologies. The brothers validator incurred a penalty of 1 ETH for proposing two blocks during the same Ethereum block production slot.

Court rejects prosecutions arguments over MEV-Boost software

Another part of the governments case concerned invalid information contained in a digitally signed block header submitted to the Ultrasound Relay during Omakase.

Clarke acknowledged that the information was incorrect, but trial evidence established that the relay did not examine the disputed fields before releasing the blocks transaction data.

The purportedly false information consequently “had no impact on the behavior of its recipient,” the judge wrote.

Prosecutors did not present an expert witness on Ethereums trading environment or call a representative from Ultrasound during the trial. Only one of the three sandwich traders who suffered losses provided testimony.

Clarke cited the separate 2025 wire fraud ruling involving Mango Markets trader Avraham Eisenberg, where the court found that other users expectations about the operation of a cryptocurrency platform did not establish that the defendant had made a false promise.

Ethereum prosecution ends more than two years after arrests

As crypto.news previously reported, U.S. authorities arrested the brothers in May 2024 following an investigation involving the Internal Revenue Services Criminal Investigation unit.

Each of the original three charges carried a maximum potential prison sentence of 20 years.

In July 2025, Clarke rejected an earlier motion to dismiss the fraud charges, although a separate charge of conspiracy to receive stolen property was dismissed after prosecutors decided not to pursue it.

The November 2026 ruling found that the evidence presented at trial could not sustain the wire fraud charges. The money laundering conspiracy charge depended on the proceeds of the alleged fraud and therefore failed as well.

Court records show that Flashbots temporarily blacklisted the validator involved in Omakase and updated its relay software within 24 hours of the incident.

A cryptocurrency wallet containing $3 million of the proceeds was frozen, while the brothers had converted their remaining profits into U.S. dollars by October 2023.

면책 성명

본 기사의 견해는 저자의 개인적 견해일 뿐이며 본 플랫폼은 투자 권고를 하지 않습니다. 본 플랫폼은 기사 내 정보의 정확성, 완전성, 적시성을 보장하지 않으며, 개인의 기사 내 정보에 의한 손실에 대해 책임을 지지 않습니다.
전편

비트코인 실현 손실 지표, 6월 고점 경신…미결제약정은 2년 저점 주시

다음

비트코인 ETF, 크립토퀀트가 약세 국면을 지적하면서 2억 4,000만 달러 유출